I think Picard had a lot less people die under him then Kirk. Also I truly believe he could kick my butt.

janeway cause she can adapt and had the hardest job out of all of them. But I also really liked Picard, but deffinitly have to go for Janeway.

Kirk
Because he took on God, AND WON,
He's the most hated and feared man in the galaxy (ask any klingon)

Kirk.
Chicks dig him and dudes want to be him.
While Picard's trying to negotiate and Janeway's trying NOT to sound like Kate Hepburn and Archer is asking, "What's a photon torpedo?" and Sisko is telling folks to call him 'Hawk'... Kirk has set phasers to FUBAR, won the day and swaggered off into the sunset with two hot alien chicks wearing tinfoil go-go boots.

Picard because he had the guts, wits AND brains...

Sisko. He has the USS Defiant and he punched Q!

Mr. Spock, 'cuz he's the best char Star Trek ever produced.

Sisko, he was the only captain to ever punch Q.

Q: "You hit me! Picard never hit me!"
Sisko: "I'm not Picard."

-trinity