Bakula ftw

I went with Picard on the notion that Riker would knock his old ass out and takeover.

Then the ship would fly around blowing shit up, and then we'd all get hookers and blow on Risa.

AWESOME.

Picard, he's the smartest.

Picard, He's Just Fuckn' Awsome.

Kirk was first, Janeway was fairly underrated, but my money'll go to Picard every time.

He WAS the Best of Both Worlds. Oh yeah.

Sisko. I'd consider him the least rash, and wisest commander. He doesn't take unnecessary risks or anything like that.

Picard = whiney punk.
Kirk = jackass.
Janeway = constant B*tch.
Archer = Frat boy.

Sisko = the most comanding captian EVER.

That is all.

While this is a trick question. "The answers always Picard."

I'd have to go with Sisko.
As *notanothervillain put it, he was the only one to hit Q.
Here you have a Captain that gets put, Purposely, at the ass end of the Alpha quadrant.
And unlike other Captains that try and tout their "holier that tho" morals. When push comes to shove he tells everyone "to get bent".